Second Circuit rules remote storage DVR is legal!

News:  In a very important decision, in The Cartoon Network v. C.S.C. Holdings, Inc., the Second Circuit (in NY) reversed a trial court’s decision in favor of copyright holders against cable companies planning to use a “remote storage” DVR.  The opinion is here.

A remote storage DVR means that the actual digital files are stored, not in the set top box in a person’s home, but instead remotely on the servers of the cable companies.  The functionality, however, is the same:  TV viewers want to “time shift” record shows for later viewing.  The Sony case in 1984 recognized the fair use right of viewers to time shift record on the VCR.  The “remote storage” DVR takes the storage from the home to some remote server.  

Several media companies representing copyright holders said that this change made the recording illegal b/c it was no longer taking place in the home.  The trial court agreed, but, interestingly, no fair use argument was considered in the analysis because the parties apparently did not present it.  So the decision turned on analyzing whether the remote storage constituted direct infringement.  On appeal, the Second Circuit held that it did not and reversed the trial court’s decision.


3 Responses to Second Circuit rules remote storage DVR is legal!

  1. John Feeney says:

    Here come the Pirates, selling/trading an monetizing libraries of content all under the flag of Fair Use.

  2. nancyprager says:

    Fair use was not an issue in this case. The claim was for direct infringement by a commercial party (one element of fair use is that the use must not be commercial). The court noted that the plaintiffs did not pursue a contributory infringement claim. That is, the role of the consumer (the end user) was not at at issue. Had a contributory infringement claim been made the court would have had to consider whether or not the consumer’s use of the content was infringing, or whether fair use applied.


  3. John Feeney says:


    Thank you for clearing that up and setting me straight…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: