Is YouTube really “killing our culture,” as Andrew Keen says?

June 20, 2007

Book review: Andrew Keen has a book just out, provocatively titled, “The Cult of the Amateur: How Today’s Internet Is Killing Our Culture.” In the book, Keen launches into a tirade against YouTube, Wikipedia, the entire blogosphere, and all other user-generated or “amateur” content in our Web 2.0 world. Keen’s basic thesis is this: “[D]emocratization [on the Internet], despite its lofty idealization, is undermining truth, souring civic discourse, and belittling expertise, experience, and talent. … [I]t is threatening the very future of our cultural institutions” (15). Yes, according to Keen, YouTube is a big part of the problem.

Over the next few days, I’ll be reviewing this book. Today, let me begin with two points.

1. The rhetoric in the book. It’s filled with punchy writing and clever turns of phrase. The rhetoric is often fun to read, in part because it’s so over-the-top. But I think the rhetoric ultimately undermines Keen’s own message. Keen says he wants more detailed, reasoned professional analysis. But his own book sensationalizes stories and speaks with the same kind of overgeneralizations and rantings that Keen criticizes on amateur blogs. Keen is taking a contrarian view on Web 2.0, and because his book is being mass-marketed, he’s more likely to sell books if his position is more sensationalized or extreme.

2. Is Keen himself an amateur?: Keen decries the amateur and hails the professional expert as the source of “truth” (more on truth in a later post). But what kind of expert is Keen? From his own bio, he’s a Silicon Valley entrepreneur who once was a CEO of a dot com and who now is CEO of “afterTV LLC, a firm that helps marketers optimize their brand desirability in the post-TV consumer landscape.” Oh, and, of course, Keen has his own blog.

OK, so does that make Keen an expert in democracy, freedom of the press, journalism, the entertainment industry, the music industry, intellectual property, libel law, click fraud, identity theft, and child predators–topics all covered in his book? My point is not to attack Keen’s credentials, but to question his overall argument in his book–that “amateur” productions should be kept in check because they are ruining “our culture” (more on “our culture” later). If that were the rule, his book shouldn’t have been published at all.  The people at Doubleday should have edited out any bit of material for which Keen had no expertise.

Justin Timberlake buys Esmee Denters ad on YouTube

June 20, 2007

News:  Justin Timberlake just bought a huge banner ad on YouTube for Esmee Denters.  I’ve never seen a YouTube celebrity get her own ad on YouTube, until now.


BBC interview with Chad Hurley + Steve Chen

June 20, 2007

News:  A full write-up and video can be found here.

YouTube taking over the UK … and the Internet

June 20, 2007

News: Two interesting statistics came out this week. 80% of Internet users in the UK over 15 years of age streamed video in April, with 38% of the streams coming from YouTube or Google. And, according to Ellacoya Networks, YouTube now comprises 10% of all Internet bandwidth consumption.

Apple’s new iPhone to have YouTube

June 20, 2007

News: Apple’s new iPhone, set for release on June 29, will play YouTube videos from the Internet. Apple has a very, very cool demo here. Watch it, it’s amazing.  Steve Jobs is one smart guy.  Apple also just put YouTube into Apple TV.